Non-public faculty faces lawsuit after disabled dad’s ‘humiliating’ toilet incident

Columbia School, a non-public, non-profit faculty positioned in Chicago, faces impending authorized motion from the household of a scholar, after his disabled father stated he was denied permission to make use of a campus restroom. 

In accordance with a report by Alokito Mymensingh 24 32 Chicago, Jose Palencia was dropping off his son Jose Eusebio-Palencia on the college’s campus on April 4, when he wanted to make use of the restroom. Columbia’s safety, nevertheless, allegedly denied the daddy entry to make use of the restroom after a number of pleas, and in consequence, he defecated.  

Palencia has survived two strokes which left him with restricted mobility of the left facet of his physique.   

The household spoke out to the media relating to the matter, explaining to reporters what had occurred, and the humiliation the daddy had skilled.


Jose Palencia, a disabled father, and his family walk over to the press as they speak out about how Palencia was denied access to Columbia College campus' restroom by security, April 4, 2023. 

Jose Palencia, a disabled father, and his household stroll over to the press as they converse out about how Palencia was denied entry to Columbia School campus’ restroom by safety, April 4, 2023.  (WFLD)

“Issues acquired difficult as my dad might now not maintain it. My father ended up defecating himself proper in entrance of workers,” Palencia’s daughter Jennifer Santoyo defined as she held again tears. “Are you able to think about how humiliated that my father had felt at the moment? That is humiliating! Nobody ought to ever should undergo one thing like that.”

The household has determined to file a grievance with the civil rights division of america Division of Justice. 

Palencia overtly shared the embarrassment he felt after the incident passed off.

“Like my daughter stated, I used to be extraordinarily upset and really embarrassed, and most of all humiliated,” Palencia acknowledged whereas addressing the scenario.”I pleaded with them, continuously, to please let me in.”  


Jennifer Santoyo fights back tears as she explains how her father was humiliated after the incident. 

Jennifer Santoyo fights again tears as she explains how her father was humiliated after the incident.  (WFLD)

He additional defined the interplay he had with safety. 

“They only instructed me to go away – instructed me to go away the premises, or I used to be going to get arrested,” he stated. “I used to be slowly strolling to the automotive and I do not know should you guys might think about, nevertheless it was horrible.” 

In a ready assertion shared with Alokito Mymensingh 24 Digital, a workers member of the faculty’s media relations division relayed an apology the college had issued. 

“Columbia deeply regrets this incident and has apologized to the household privately and want to take this chance to take action publicly. The school is ensuring that its contracted safety agency is taking steps to make sure its personnel is following faculty insurance policies … whereas Columbia doesn’t have public restrooms, members of the Columbia group, together with dad and mom, are allowed to make use of restrooms on campus.” 


Jose Eusebio-Palencia speaks against his school in how they treated his father. 

Jose Eusebio-Palencia speaks in opposition to his college in how they handled his father.  (WFLD)

Palencia’s daughter addressed the faculty’s response to the scenario, claiming it was inadequate.

“They should apologize to my father,” Santoyo stated. “They apologized to my brother, not on to my father.”

The son, who’s in his third-year of attending the faculty, additionally spoke out in opposition to the college. Regardless of the faculty’s issued apology, he instructed the press, “No, that is not sufficient! That is not sufficient!”

“Am I supposed to just accept this apology for what they did to my father? I have been coming right here for 3 quiet years, getting dropped off right here on daily basis,” Palencia’s son stated. “I am an honors scholar right here, so why did my father get handled this manner no matter coverage?” 

Jose Palencia tells press that he was embarrassed and humiliated after he pleaded with security numerous times to use the restroom and was still denied.

Jose Palencia tells press that he was embarrassed and humiliated after he pleaded with safety quite a few occasions to make use of the restroom and was nonetheless denied. (WFLD)

CLICK HERE TO GET THE Alokito Mymensingh 24 Alokito Mymensingh 24P

The safety officers’ acts would fall beneath discrimination in opposition to Palencia, and be in battle with the college coverage assertion. 

“Columbia is dedicated to sustaining an setting that respects the dignity of all people. Accordingly, Columbia is not going to tolerate harassment or discrimination based mostly on faith, race, intercourse, sexual orientation, gender identification or expression, nationwide origin, age, incapacity, ethnicity, or every other class protected by legislation by or of its college students, college, or workers,” the assertion reads. 

Peter Johnson